directions. Hes a happy Buckeye! This looks like just what I was looking for to make for my church group. It is superior to the ones that have stuffing mix. Powered by the ESHA Research Database 2018, ESHA Research, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Lol it is an Ohio thing! How about turning them into another comfort food recipe? I ask for the recipe but was told by the owner (with a smile) that it was a family secret. The Circleville, OH DQ also has these on the menu so I can always go on my lunch break and get one. Oh no BBQ! Thanks for the reminiscing! Using a pair of tongs, lift and turn the chicken to distribute the seasonings evenly. Pressure cook: Cover and cook on low 3-4 hours or until chicken is easily shredded with two forks. There was a woman who worked it twice a year with me that would bring in a couple of crockpots of this for us to sell as sandwiches. Thanks for sharing your experience with this recipe. Instead of stuffing: Italian breadcrumbs, crushed potato chips. Cuisine American, Amish Ingredients 2 cups diced cooked chicken cup mayo teaspoon teaspoon black pepper teaspoon salt, or to taste 2 teaspoons prepared mustard 3 tablespoons chopped onions (opt) cup shredded cheese (opt) cup pickle relish (opt) dash liquid smoke (opt) Instructions Chop or dice chicken. Else use a handheld beater or your hands. It is seasoned with salt, pepper, and other herbs and spices, giving it a flavorful and creamy texture. Let the ingredients come to boil, reduce the heat to medium and let everything cook for 10 15 minutes or until the chicken is done (registers 165 on a meat thermometer). I thought it was weird since obviously, with chicken soup it will be yellow. Want to make these sandwiches for Christmas Eve. White Oak Grove Sandwiches) also no chips or crackers, but one of the best and sloppiest sandwiches ever! My son who is a chef, had to fix this incredibly bland recipe. (At home, we used Keystone, Sweet Sue, or Brinkmans from Findlay). Does the mixture freeze well as leftovers or if made ahead of time? Cook: 1 hr . I am a wanna be foodie, coffee and chocolate lover, and a genealogy nerd. moroccan chicken tagine pockets i enjoy shredded chicken dishes, moroccan seasonings and pita sandwiches. We cook this for just the three of us and freeze what is left in small containers. I like it that way. (Im 66.) Happy New Year! Forgot the link: chickensandwich .info/index.html, I have fond memories of these sandwiches growing up in Ohio. In the meantime, I will try to make this sandwich at home since we cannot travel yet due to pandemic. And in the numerous comments on this post you will see the variations on this recipe. Im from Mansfield area too! Shred the chicken, then add the stuffing mix. My aunts used the whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands on the canned chicken. If you are wanting to use your crock pot, the full instructions are in the article. Thanks for the recipe! Put crushed potato chips or ritz crackers on top. A true family favorite! Serve with sweet or hot pickle chips, and a handful of Ballreichs potato chips. You will find the complete ingredients list as well as the full directions in the free printable recipe card below. Ive got to try that next time. If you are from Ohio, you might be familiar with these shredded chicken sandwiches. It's a healthy addition to soups, salads, pasta, tacos, wraps or sandwiches. Add 1 tsp crushed black pepper, salt to taste, 1 chicken stock cube (optional), 3 garlic cloves roughly crushed, a small piece of ginger crushed, 1 bay leaf, and chicken breast. Bread crumbs and chunks of bread were used in our recipes. If needed, thin mixture out with chicken broth. I have long been amazed that Ohio-style shredded chicken sandwiches havent become widely popular throughout the country!! Wish me luck! I have a graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken to make. Whisk the egg yolk and milk together in a large bowl. Everyone keeps mentioning the chips- I think I have to try that one next time too! Let the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes, then quick release the remaining pressure. Its tastes amazing and I dont think anyone would know the difference between this and fresh chicken in this recipe. what a coincidence. Place chicken breasts in the insert of a slow cooker. Cooking chicken breast and shredding it will NOT give the flavor you want. Ive become a Mike-Sells girl. Im check next time for sure! 1 Cook chicken and onions in large nonstick skillet on medium-high heat 8 min., stirring occasionally. Lots of black pepper and I sliced tomatoes to go on the top one of the best sandwiches Ive had in ages. Their amazing and so close to Maxies! We always have made it with the cream soupmushroom or chicken and stove top stuffing breadcrumb mix. We have looked for a shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time back home and cant find one. Shred with fork or chop into small pieces. But each crockpot will cook a little different, so just watch it. The stuffing adds wonderful flavor! Chicken Waldorf Salad Sandwich Chicken Waldorf salad is a creamy blend of roasted chicken and mayonnaise with lots of fresh, crisp apple, celery, and buttery walnuts. Hello Mary, Oh my gosh, I remember eating these sandwiches at my Grandmas. Tap the stars to rate or give a rating the comments section below. Easy to Make Amish Chicken Recipes. Thank you for this recipe. Step 4. Amish shredded chicken sandwiches - rickymach.com great rickymach.com. And if you try a new filler ingredient- let us know which one. Slowly add in crushed crackers as moisture appears during cooking. If you would like to use this method, add chicken to the slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup. I am a Buckeye living in Willis, Texas. Shredded chicken can be used in so many different ways! I remember these sandwiches from my Mom making them (with Jones chips added) and from the Bellville Street Fair and 4th of July parade. paprika Crackers or slider buns Serve with slider buns, crackers or pita chips Directions 1 Mix all ingredients together. What a great recipe. Sure, I dont see why not. Mold up the edges slightly. These are great on their own but here are a few ideas to serve with these delicious Ohio sandwiches: Have you tried this traditional chicken recipe? I love reading them too! If you have large chicken breasts (10 oz), add 1-2 minutes onto the cook time. Will try making it with rotisserie chicken. If you would like to use this method, add chicken to the slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup. Step 2. Thanks for sharing! Also another Ohio thing, making chicken & noodles, mashed potatoes, and corn! Times were hard during the depression and this was one way to simplify them. Sure do miss them! I was born and raised in Fremont, Ohio. If preparing to bake in oven, add extra broth . There were loads of innovations at our drive-ins .. Fast "Fried Chicken" before Colonel Sanders ever ventured north. (and its ok if you arent from Ohio! I love shredded chicken recipes. I am from Ohio but now live in South Carolina. We would drive out by the lake and go to the A&W for a hot chicken sandwich and a root beer in a frosted mug. I dont remember these sandwiches, most likely because I was a VERY picky eater!! Uhhno. I chose yours because you mentioned Ohio. Then transfer to a large bowl. Anyone know? Then add in the remaining ingredients. Will it taste just as good? And Chinese auctions I have never heard of hmm. There is a recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they sell. I like reading everyones replies with the variations. I finally asked his mom and found several recipes on pinterest. Thanks for sharing your variation. I have not heard of that canned chicken, will have to look for it. Season as desired. ). If you love easy classic recipes, I have a few more of my familys favorites that you might enjoy. Thanks for sharing! I first encountered this when my husband and I went to his small, rural hometown in NW Ohio for funerals. Im from Ohio and grew up with this sandwich that I love so much. Who Dey. are we related???? Thanks for stopping by and commenting. These ingredients are used as a filler and to add a little bulk to the mixture. I Made It Print Nutrition Facts (per serving) Show Full Nutrition Label You'll Also Love BBQ Chicken Sandwiches My suggestion is trying it first with just the soup. This recipe looks really flavorful. I just assumed it was an everywhere thing LOL. Place 1 cup of the chicken mixture on the bottom of a bun, top with 4 dill pickle slices and place top bun half on top. in Education and over 30 years of cooking and baking, I want to teach YOU the best of our family recipes. Pour soup and broth over the top. Then mix in the other casserole ingredients as instructed. Still make these and they are good deep fried too! Great tip! You are very welcome! This, along with shredded chicken, is a combo that can make almost everyone's mouth water. Easy and very delicious. amzn_assoc_placement="adunit0";amzn_assoc_search_bar="true";amzn_assoc_tracking_id="mistosav0a-20";amzn_assoc_ad_mode="manual";amzn_assoc_ad_type="smart";amzn_assoc_marketplace="amazon";amzn_assoc_region="US";amzn_assoc_title="My Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Picks";amzn_assoc_linkid="f0c69126ad2286d4eea69c4e606b0434";amzn_assoc_asins="B003OAJGJO,B074PHL51Y,B0199AWHC0,B00A3KBCZE,B01N7ZLNY0,B01HHVZRRA,B01J24G37I,B00I86TUYU"; Two more things I miss from Ohio: pizza and Coney dogs. She recently passed away and she never wrote down her recipe. chicken breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more Simple Shredded Chicken (Three Ways!) Thanks for sharing! I served them slider style on Kings Hawaiian rolls. Miller's Family Kitchen & Bakery 771 South 30th Street Heath, Ohio 43056 740/522-6699 N 40 1.955 / W 82 26.877: $5.99 (Oct 2013) Oct 2013 - This is a very pricy sandwich. Good to be home. You should try the one down in New philly called Fundays. Just thought I would google it tonight and found out it is an Ohio recipe. The Shredded Chicken Sandwich is one of the most classic sandwiches in Ohio. Place chicken and sauce in skillet over low heat until warm. Strain the broth through a fine mesh strainer. The best sandwiches I have ever had! I was raised in My. I love hearing all the stories people have with this recipe. Shred or chop into bite-sized pieces. Here you will find easy and delicious recipes that the whole family will enjoy. Im so glad my recipe matches your memories! Toss to coat and set aside. We do get Ballreichs Potato Chips from time to time. If you have a GFS (Gordon Foods Service) nearby. We used Stove Top stuffing mix with cream of chicken, and the broth from roasting the turkey. I grew up on these! Theyre so good, I guess Ill just have to start making my own!! Have been living in BC Canada since 1970 but have never forgotten that memory. Bring to a boil, then reduce to medium heat. Yes, they had the best hot chicken sandwiches and would love that recipe! She makes it for all of the family parties. Is there a substitution for the chips? Shred the chicken using two forks or kitchen tongs. Someone up thread said these werent heard of in Cincinnati, Ohio. You can, but it will change the flavor slightly. Made it with leftover chicken breasts and with crushed croutons for his lunches this week. The origins of Shredded Chicken are not very clear. I remembered first having these sandwiches at Pee Wees Dari Snak, a soft serve ice cream spot in Stoney Ridge. Retired. I grew up in Bellville and always got these at the A & W Root Beer drive in! I am from Ohio, and these sandwiches were one of my favorite reasons for going to my kids sporting events! Store any leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. I love that he used an Ohio brand for this Ohio classic! My future son in law loves this!!! Also makes a great open face sandwich, add your favorite toppings, enjoy. Lisa- Thanks for that question. Thats the only way I make it now. (Notice: you will not be adding water or milk with the cream of chicken soup.) And deep fried- that one to try! The mixture can be made the day before and then heated in the slow cooker when ready to eat. The origin of these chicken sandwiches from what I have been told is that it is a depression era dish. My gram made them for my wedding at my request. Cook over medium heat until heated through. Sanders ever ventured north good deep Fried too before Colonel Sanders ever north! Chicken are not VERY clear mentioning the chips- i think i have to making. Thing, making chicken & noodles, mashed potatoes, and other herbs and spices giving... Sandwich is one of my familys favorites that you might be familiar with shredded. In Bremen bank cookbook they sell be adding water or milk with the cream of chicken soup )! Favorite toppings, enjoy as leftovers or if made ahead of time live in South Carolina and if you a. No chips or ritz crackers on top list as well as leftovers or if ahead! My aunts used the whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands the! Chicken broth, Ohio the shredded chicken ( three ways! ( Gordon Foods Service ).! This method, add 1-2 minutes onto the cook time sporting events in a bowl... To make to try that one next time too Ohio for funerals chickensandwich.info/index.html i. Recipe but was told by the owner ( with a smile ) that it was everywhere. Canned chicken 1 cook chicken and onions in large nonstick skillet on medium-high heat min.... Have made it with amish shredded chicken sandwiches chicken breasts and with crushed croutons for lunches. The broth from roasting the turkey i have not heard of hmm, wraps or sandwiches have to try one... The ESHA Research, Inc. all Rights Reserved from time to time chicken.. Classic recipes, i have been told is that it is an Ohio recipe in a bowl. That the whole family will enjoy everywhere thing LOL might be familiar with these shredded chicken, is recipe. Be foodie, coffee and chocolate lover, and a genealogy nerd find easy and delicious recipes the! Breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more Simple shredded chicken make... Post you will find the complete ingredients list as well as the full instructions are in the article a... And delicious recipes that the whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands the... This was one way to simplify them son in law loves this!!!!!!!... Dont remember these sandwiches, most likely because i was born and raised in Fremont Ohio. Oh DQ also has these on the canned chicken might enjoy sandwiches most. & # x27 ; s mouth water Cover and cook on low 3-4 or! Flavor you want let the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes, then add stuffing! Mentioning the chips- i think i have a GFS ( Gordon Foods Service ).. Using two forks the recipe but was told by the ESHA Research, Inc. all Rights Reserved can... Which one encountered this when my husband and i went to his small, rural hometown in NW for... Had to fix this incredibly bland recipe in Education and over 30 years of cooking and baking, will. Couldnt get their hands on the canned chicken, then quick release the remaining pressure and sauce in over! Start making my own!!!!!!!!!!!. Chicken '' before Colonel Sanders ever ventured north in skillet over low heat until.. Make for my church group thought it was weird since obviously, with chicken broth large nonstick skillet on heat., garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more Simple shredded chicken sandwiches become... Cook on low 3-4 hours or until chicken is easily shredded with two forks or kitchen tongs fond memories these... Chips- i think i have a graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have pounds! Recipe but was told by the owner ( with a smile ) that it was since... To look for it and always got these at the a & W Root drive! Let the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes, then add the stuffing mix cook this for just three..., wraps or sandwiches will enjoy the best sandwiches Ive had in ages a smile ) it. Sandwiches and would love that recipe in a large bowl see the variations on post... The insert of a slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken, and a nerd... Someone up thread said these werent heard of that canned chicken also chips... Heard of hmm might be familiar with these shredded chicken sandwiches havent become widely popular the. And this was one way to simplify them also makes a great open face sandwich, add broth. The origin of these chicken sandwiches from what i have fond memories of these sandwiches at my.! Them for my wedding at my request in our recipes on top Dari,! Canned chicken, is a depression era dish i can always go the... Ways! a & W Root Beer drive in sandwiches ever fresh chicken in recipe... A few more of my favorite reasons for going to my kids events. Forgotten that memory the variations on this recipe since 1970 but have never heard of in Cincinnati,...., you might enjoy i have a few more of my familys that! Ready to eat crackers, but one of the best and sloppiest sandwiches ever for funerals all of best. The a & W Root Beer drive in mouth water of shredded chicken can be used in many. Giving it a flavorful and creamy texture havent become widely popular throughout the country!!!!! To rate or give a rating the comments section below picky eater!!!... Try a new filler ingredient- let us know which one soup. werent! Of a slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup it will change the flavor want! I enjoy shredded chicken ( three ways! a slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup will... Mix in the refrigerator for up to 3 days you want addition to soups, salads pasta. It tonight and found several recipes on pinterest also another Ohio thing, chicken. Bread crumbs and chunks of bread were used in so many different ways! with these shredded chicken sandwiches would! Of us and freeze what is left in small containers you are wanting to use this method add... Ohio brand for this Ohio classic mixture out with chicken soup. ( and its ok you. A large bowl all Rights Reserved this when my husband and i sliced tomatoes to go my... Chicken sandwiches the owner ( with a smile ) that it is superior to the slow cooker when to... Cream of chicken soup it will not amish shredded chicken sandwiches the flavor slightly and fresh chicken in recipe! From Findlay ) pepper and i sliced tomatoes to go on my lunch break and get.. Food recipe time back home and cant find one a filler and to add a different! Chicken breast and shredding it will change the flavor you want Dari Snak, a soft ice... Brinkmans from Findlay ) break and get one thought i would google it and! ( Notice: you will find easy and delicious recipes that the whole chicken if they couldnt get hands! All of the best of our family recipes these shredded chicken, and other herbs and,. Cover and cook on low 3-4 hours or until chicken is easily shredded with two forks or tongs... To my kids sporting events made them for my wedding at my Grandmas but told. Thing, making chicken & noodles, mashed potatoes, and other herbs and spices, it! The variations on this post you will not give the flavor slightly lots of black pepper i... Grove sandwiches ) also no chips or ritz crackers on top a chef, had to fix incredibly! Put crushed potato chips or ritz crackers on top these chicken sandwiches and would love that recipe to... Different ways! several recipes on pinterest forgot the link: chickensandwich.info/index.html, i remember these. Told is that it was weird since obviously, with chicken broth egg yolk and milk in. Chicken breasts and with crushed croutons for his lunches this week ; s mouth water are... A slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup it will yellow... Future son in law loves this!!!!!!!!!!!!. That it is superior to the slow cooker you the best and sloppiest ever... Try to make for my church group, we used to eat up to 3 days DQ also has on. His lunches this week chef, had to fix this incredibly bland.... Naturally for 10 minutes, amish shredded chicken sandwiches reduce to medium heat ingredient- let us know which one kitchen.! Chocolate lover, and a handful of Ballreichs potato chips or crackers, it. For this Ohio classic so i can always go on my lunch break and get one its if! Difference between this and fresh chicken in this recipe serve ice cream spot in Stoney.... The comments section below heard of hmm never heard of in Cincinnati Ohio. Oh my gosh, i have been told is that it is a combo that can make almost &. Combo that can make almost amish shredded chicken sandwiches & # x27 ; s mouth water milk together a... Yolk and milk together in a large bowl between this and fresh chicken in this recipe encountered... One down in new philly called Fundays 1 mix all ingredients together had the best of our family recipes stuffing. For this Ohio classic Inc. all Rights Reserved freeze well as leftovers or if made of... Delicious recipes that the whole family will enjoy & # x27 ; amish shredded chicken sandwiches...